Showing posts with label Policy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Policy. Show all posts

Saturday, December 19, 2009

The Fallacy of the Carbon Market

Coal power plant in Datteln (Germany) at the D...Image via Wikipedia

The noise surrounding Copenhagen is deafening. Hidden within the noise and light are several elephant sized questions that everyone seems to be ignoring. Firstly, is carbon pricing really an effective market? Secondly, can a market based solution be found that doesn't involve pricing carbon? My answers to those questions are no and yes respectively.

Carbon trading is unlikely to be a very good market. Not only is it hard to monitor, verify and account; the very difficulties in in monitoring, verification and accounting leave the market wide open to gaming and manipulation. It is quite possible that it will cost more to run a carbon market with less improvement in emmissions than to spend the money on direct measures to improve emissions.

So are there other market-based solutions that are as effective if not more effective than carbon trading? Almost certainly. The whole conversation around climate change has become so tunneled vision on carbon trading that other market based solutions are ignored. Lets step back from the particulars of carbon trading to look at what is being trying to accomplish.

The idea is to use price signals to encourage changes in participant behaviour and resource allocation. In the case of climate change it is to reduce greenhouse gas emissions with the price of carbon as the signalling mechanism. Why carbon price was alighted on one can only speculate(special interest groups such as investment banks looking for the next CDO scam comes to mind and green zealots with a messiah complex) but in reality it can be any pricing (or more than one pricing) signal as long as it accomplishes the goal. All that is required is a pricing signal that change the way energy is generated and used.

A fallacy of the debate is that regulatory regimes are inherently, non-market based. That is untrue. If the regulatory regime specifies the mechanisms of reduction then it isn't market-based. But if the regulatory regime specifies the end goal and then leaves it up to the market to produce the most effective solution, that is a market-based solution. Before rushing to say that isn't true bear in mind that is exactly what the carbon trading market is, a regulatory regime that specifies an end goal and leaves it up to market participants to allocate the resources to produce the reduction desired.

A carbon market is one of many possible markets that will produce the goal of changing the way energy is generated and used. Nor is there anything to say it is the most effective regime and I am coming to the conclusion that a carbon market is probably the worst possible market to achieve this goal. The carbon market strays into specifying the mechanism rather than the goal.

An alternative market would be based on a regime that specifies work per unit energy input requirement, or efficiency. A set time points the efficiency requirement would increase contiuning to drive changes in energy production and consumption.

There are several benefits to this market:
  1. it is simpler for people to understand - energy and its use is far more concrete than an invisible gas
  2. measuring & accounting for efficiency is far, far easier than measuring & accounting for emissions
  3. its harder to outsource consumption and generation in an efficiency focus regime
  4. the measure efficiency can be tailored to different industry sectors but still tied back to an overall measure
  5. it is harder for free-riders to prosper as each industry has their own targets
  6. and doesn't fall afoul of the rather significant problem that the physics of converting to a carbon free economy don't stack up

Technically this type of market is viable but is it politically viable? From my persepctive it is. It is easier to explain to sceptical citizens, targets are based on improvements rather than reductions and allows various players to choose the mechanisms that suit them best. Using efficiency targets becomes globally homogeneous avoiding the brutal and almost politically impossible task assigning blame and reductions according to blame. Nor does it require everyone to sign-up initially. As efficiency is measured at point of consumption, if a large proportion of global consumption uses efficiency targets, suppliers and producers will need to adapt to meet those targets in essence becoming part of the solution should those producers and suppliers wish to trade with that market.

There are other possible market-based solutions as well. We would do ourselves and the world a favour to not tunnel vision on carbon markets but to pick the best market-based solution that produces the desired behaviour of changing energy production and consumption.
Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Monday, June 01, 2009

What can be done about North Korea and the Bomb?

North Korea undertook their second nuclear explosion and is firing off missiles that is more reminisce of someone trying compensate for a small dick. The UN Security Council will probably pass a resolution that by and large will do nothing. China will keep propping up the regime for both political and strategic reasons, South Korea is limited by what it wants to do and Japan will probably make the strongest moves to "punish" North Korea by beefing up missile defences.

Peter Hatcher puts forward what he thinks will make the regime pay attention to the international community. In effect it is having China, South Korea and Japan cut off cashflow to the regime. Sensible, but I am not convinced that any of those countries will do what is necessary particular as it doesn't meet their strategic aims.

Short of military action is there anything that can be done? It is a question that I've been pondering over the last week or so. Nothing leaps out as a great solution but a remembered article from years back about how information is probably the best weapon against the regime stirs.

The idea (as I remember it) was to air drop self-contained internet access devices that would provide the populace with access to the outside world that wasn't controlled by the regime. As much as the idea seems fanciful, I think a variant on it is something to consider.

In the variant, use OLPC-like laptops with windy handles for powering the device. The devices will need to include a verbal interface so that people who are illiterate can use it. The main issue is how to provide outside access? One potential way is to include a satellite access device that also acts as a wireless access point. Bearing in mind that as OLPC laptops can create mesh networks large numbers of the hubs would not be needed. Indeed, additional access could be provided by wireless connections beamed in from South Korea and naval ships.

The aim of internet access devices is to break the strangle hold on information that the regime has. That opens the door to working around the regime to provide food, water and power. In effect the internet access devices (remembering they can be used to share information and coordinate activity within North Korea as well) allows new centres of power to form and for the people to negate the advantages the regime has.

Would it work? I don't know and I don't think anyone really does. Anthropologists and psychologists can give you an estimate of potential effects it would have but until it is tried we won't know. So should it be done? I think it should be seriously be considered. At the very least it would be another potential noose to tighten around the regime's neck.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Thursday, May 21, 2009

Making the Economy Robust To Black Swans

Cygnus atratusImage via Wikipedia

In a recent twitter conversation about managing chaotic systems by pushing the system to linear instead of non-linear responses to shocks.

Which does lead to the question can you have linear response to shocks in a non-linear system? Short answer is yes. Even in non-linear system there is a portion of response that is linear, with the response becoming non-linear with further driving.

In effect you structure the system (with dampeners etc) based on the potential response of the system to the shock. This method doesn’t plan based on a probability of an event occurring rather based on what would happen to the system should the shock occur. The aim isn’t to prevent shocks rather control how the system (in this case the economy) reacts to shocks.

Economic systems respond to shocks in 2 ways by destroying demand and freezing of money (or credit). Unfortunately, the responses are coupled and one will cause the other which in turns feeds back in. The key is to keep either from precipitating the other.

The money freeze occurs as the system tries to workout where the risk is. An event has occurred (such as a failing institution) that has demonstrated that the risk in the system is not understood. Money stops flowing as everyone aims to identify where and who has the risk.

To dampen this response:
  • Ensure all financial transactions are transparent. This involves using marketplaces and exchanges and avoiding all trading in financial instruments over the counter.
  • Reduce the amount of risk that is in question by structuring the economy so financial institutions can never large.
The demand destruction is as it’s name suggest the removal of demand from the system. An event has occurred such as the explosion in price of a key input over a very short time (such as the oil shock of the 1970s) that creates a situation of mass layoffs reducing the demand within the economy.
To dampen this response:
  • Provide a system that allows private demand to be replaced quickly by public demand (i.e. infrastructure building)
  • Reduce the loss of demand by income smoothing that avoids people suddenly reducing spending drastically as they are laid off
It is reasonable to point out these dampeners are already in place. Yes to extent they are but it is ad hoc and not very effective as currently done. Take for example the demand replacement. Many countries have proposed infrastructure programs. However, these don’t get underway (the building aspect) for a period of years. The demand needs to be replaced immediately not in 2 years time when private demand will be increasing. Instead, projects that create public demand need to be maintained at a point that allows them to be instigated within 3 months.

While unemployment benefits go towards smoothing income, it still results in a massive reduction in demand as unemployment benefits a pegged at subsistence level. To smooth income properly, a program of income-contingent loans for redundancies and training are needed that avoid the drastic reduction in for a period of 6 to 18 months.

Focusing on system response to shocks instead of trying to model the probability of shocks moves us away from the realm of make-believe that is probability forecasting to focusing on making the economy more robust and able to handle Nassim Taleb's Black Swan events.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Wednesday, April 08, 2009

Open Access Will Make the NBN Work, not Price

Ok this is getting ridiculous. There is lots of commentary going on in the Australian press and from the politicians about the NBN. Most of it inane and demonstrating the commenter's complete lack of understanding about the technology and the issue.

The NBN will provide economic, social and environmental benefits. This fascination and indeed obsession with cost of access is self-defeating. Here is a quick overview of the benefits

  • Economic: NBN improves access to SaaS solutions and increases effective collaboration both improving producing and reducing costs. NBN opens up new possibilities for new companies and industries that hadn't existing before. Could anyone have predicted YouTube or Twitter when we were using 56k modems? NBN brings very high speed access to businesses of all sizes rather than just the largest.
  • Social: NBN, as others pointed out, provides the ability to role out education and health applications right to where people are. Some are already talking about providing free basic access to the poor.
  • Environmental: NBN will create a boom in video calling and telepresence cutting down on travel and reducing pollution. The NBN goes a long way to reducing energy intensity of the economy.
The NBN is the convergence of communication and data. It will be used for applications ranging from video calling to web access to television and radio to smart metering to health monitoring. To see it only in the light of access misses the larger value of the NBN. Nor is the speed a big issue either. Speed through the fibre is determined by the equipment at either end and not by the cable itself. Should users and the access providers decide they can put in the equipment that supports 1Gbps without much problem. Far more than copper, fibre is future proof.

Have a look at these videos that Microsoft produced as a look into the future of computers. The NBN is the key to enabling this world.







The key to the NBN living up to its promise is how the Government structures it and it is quite possible they will get it wrong. That shouldn't stop us from trying though. Life is a risk and we cannot be afraid of making a mistake.

For the NBN to fulfil its promise the following items have to be done:
  • The conduit/real estate and fibre should be help in separate companies
  • The company sold at the end of the 5 years should only be the fibre layer and assets. The conduit/real estate company needs to remain majority Government owned.
  • The legislation has to guarantee Open Access to both the conduits (so other companies can label cabling) and the fibre.
  • Fibre should be laid direct to the house. The NBN shouldn't use shared access.
  • Access must be symmetric the same upload speed as download speed.
By embedding Open Access to the conduits and the fibre you create an environment where organisations can compete on the fibre but also at the physical layer. The largest barrier to entry remains digging up the ground and laying conduit followed by the fibre.

The Opposition needs to hold the Government to implementing the about principals. They have to work with the Government to split the construction of the NBN into two parts:
  • Building the Conduits. This is the stimulus part of the NBN and can begin quickly and should start in the large regional towns before moving to the city
  • Laying the fibre and installing the Equipment. This is the key planning stage and in order to avoid prolong delays, can be done will the conduits are being built.
The conduit building can be done by any construction company that can dig a trench, lay piping and install access points. The contracts should be standard and let out to as many of the construction companies as possible. There is no need at all for one company or small group of companies to win the contract to build all the conduits. In terms of speed by letting out contracts to various companies around Australia the construction can go on in parallel in many different locations.

The core issue here is not the price of access. It is Open Access. The Opposition must be holding the Government to providing Open Access not only to the fibre but also to the conduits. Open Access is the key to the NBN working.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Tuesday, April 07, 2009

Busting Recessions - Income Contingency Loans for Redundancy & Training

I’ve touched on income-contingency loans in previous posts, time to explore them in more detail.

Redundancy

The point of redundancy is to allow businesses to shed staff as necessary without throwing the people onto the garbage heap. The flexibility provided to hire and fire staff is important in keeping an economy resilient and flexible. Society also benefits from redundancy payments as it reduces the fear of not being able to pay bills. As most redundancies occur during recessions it helps to cushion the demand destruction of job losses.
There are two problems with redundancy systems as they currently stand:

  1. From the point of view of a person, redundancy payments are not enough to survive on, and
  2. From the point of view of the company, redundancy payments are a big hit to cashflow.
The Nordic countries use generous welfare system to reconcile the two competing interests but have high taxation as a result.

The same reconciliation of the competing interests can be achieved by using income-contingent loans. When making someone redundant the company takes out a loan from the Government to pay for the redundancy of the person. The loan is then paid back through the taxation system from the profits/income of the business taking out the loan.

Redundancy payments can then become 75-90% of final salary for a period that can last 6 to 1 year without driving businesses into the ground.

Using income contingent loans allows:
  • Businesses to lessen the impact on cashflow from redundancy payments
  • Individuals get larger payments that reflect their final salary for longer periods
  • Redundancy can be provided to all employees instead of just those that have been at the business for a long time
  • Bills, rent and mortgage continue to be paid reducing negative flow on effects from redundancy to the wider economy
  • Redundancy is guaranteed even if the company eventually goes bust

Training & Education

One of the aspects of recession is that there are too many people chasing too few jobs. Income-contingent redundancy helps lengthen the time an individual has to find another job but it isn’t the only way of smoothing things out.
The second method is to provide income-contingent loans to businesses for training employees. The business would take out an income-contingent loan that would pay for the salary and training. A modification is that the loan is jointly held by the individual and the business.

These loans would achieve:
  • Improved cashflow for the business as the employee is effectively removed from the payroll
  • The person is improving the skills and training so that they are more effective when business picks up
  • The business can hold onto good employees that would otherwise have to be made redundant
  • Less people are chasing the limited number of jobs
  • Bills, rent and mortgage continue to be paid reducing negative flow on effects of redundancy/job losses to the wider economy
  • Society benefits from better trained and skilled workforce
Income contingent loans better address the needs of business and employees without trying to jam them all into the same one-size-fits-all. They recognise the benefits of redundancy payments and training doesn’t accrue just to the business or individual or society but to all three in varying amounts.

On the face of it the training loans are better overall but training will not be suitable for all situations or occurrences. Both systems should be implemented to allow flexibility and support the uniqueness of each redundancy situation.


Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Monday, April 06, 2009

Saul Griffith, Energy Intensity and Trading Negawatts

[ebook] A History of the Science and Politics ...Image by Changhua Coast Conservation Action via Flickr

Saul Griffith of Squid Labs fame recently gave a presentation at Green:Net looking at the engineering challenge that is climate change/energy renewal. It is an informative presentation and one that builds on previous work he has done to quantify the problem. However, since seeing the math on a BBC documentary and then again in this presentation something has been bugging me and I couldn’t put my finger on it.

Saul certainly produced a fine statement of the engineering problem. Saul isn’t the first to layout the problem in that way David McKay of Cambridge University is doing a more comprehensive expose of it. Either way it is a sobering presentation.

Considered in the context of the system, though, I think some to the base assumptions may be wrong. I expect that the carbon reduction is not a linear progression but will grow slowly until a tipping point is reached at which point the carbon in the economy will drop seemingly overnight.

More importantly, the focus on carbon is leading the world astray. The primary problem isn’t carbon per se rather the energy intensity of the global economy is growing. While global energy intensity per unit GDP grows the sources of energy is relatively academic. The core problem remains the growing energy intensity per unit GDP. This is what has been bugging me about Saul's presentation - it was from the context of carbon and not about energy intensity.

To demonstrate what I mean consider Peak Oil. The Peak Oil problem is only a problem above a certain energy intensity of GDP. Below that level two effects are seen, 1) the life of oil reserves increases and (more importantly) 2) substitution for other energy sources becomes easier. By reducing the amount of oil used by reducing energy consumption less carbon is produced. The advantage is that reducing is far easier than substitution.

The answer to climate change is to set in place incentives and processes that reduce the energy intensity faster than the economy grows. Energy consumption can only be reduced when saving energy is worth more per kW than consuming energy. Some ways of doing this are:

  • Net Present Value in Energy for energy generation schemes: Like Net Present Value for evaluating monetary investment this looks at how much energy is needed over the life of the generator. All generators use energy in order to produce energy. Using NPVE will allow the comparison to see how different generation schemes reduce overall energy intensity.
  • Energy Audits: The audits would show businesses and consumers where the energy is going and suggest real changes that would make material differences to the energy they use and consume.
  • Stamp Duties/Sales blocks for low efficiency housing: Energy efficiency is in for homes with steadily rising standards but new homes only make up a small percentage of the housing stock. The biggest impact in home energy consumption will be made in improving existing housing stock. The only way to incentivise owners to improve energy consumption across the board is to either not allow the sale/rental of homes that don’t meet a certain energy standard or add an energy duty onto of the stamp duty that is determined by the energy consumption of the house.
  • Life-cycle energy labels: Transparency works wonders and the more relevant information consumers have about the products and services they consume the better purchasing decisions they can make. Providing a single number that shows how much energy is tied up in a good or service will help consumers pick products and services that consume less energy over their life and so reduce energy intensity of the economy.
In the final analysis reducing energy consumption will only be self-sustaining when the negawatt is tradable. Ultimately, personnel energy budgets or some sort of cap and trade system will work best. Trading negawatts is far more tangible than trading carbon. Carbon is intangible and there is no daily interaction with it. People understand energy; they use it every day and can see its effect. That single fact will see the far more rapid adoption of energy/negawatt trading than carbon trading.
Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Wednesday, March 04, 2009

Breaking the Financial Spiral - Part 2

London Underground Jubilee Line.Image via Wikipedia

(for part 1 see here)

This financial disaster requires some extra innovations in stimulus. Stimulus is needed from the governments simply because the massive reduction in demand brought about by job loss, credit freeze and re-balancing of household budgets. Tax cuts versus cash handouts are a red herring. The sheer amount of demand lost cannot be replaced by increasing discretionary income. Most of the consumer demand was credit based that 140 to 160% leverage of households. Trying to replace that with tax cuts or cash handouts is like trying to refill a reservoir with a bucket after the dam as broken. It’s not going to even touch the sides.

Nor can businesses replace the demand. They are inextricably tied to the crisis as businesses have been just as profligate as consumers over leveraging and not building up capital reserves. Few companies have built up cash reserves that they can use to invest during the down turn. Government handouts or tax cuts to businesses aren't going to do much to create the necessary investment in growth. Too many companies need to repair balance sheets (just like households).

The only point is for governments to step with their own demand. The idea isn't to replace all the demand lost (that will never happen) rather to break the cycle of lost demand causing further lost demand. Government stimulus initiatives need to be more direct than perhaps they have been in previous recessions. For the demand replacement to work it can't focus on make work like ditch digging. Stimulus programs need to consist of short, medium and long term that focus on energy, transport, communications and maintenance in order to produce a trajectory that gets us out of the spiral.

Short term initiatives are programmes that can be started in a very short space in time. Short term projects that would work are:
  • Insulation or wheatherisation of homes (in particular low income households),
  • Rebates, low interest loans or direct funding for households to install renewable energy systems and general energy efficiency for both households, schools, hospitals and government buildings,
  • Maintenance of roads, bridges, culverts and buildings will improve infrastructure are usually ready to go and can easily verified.
  • Re-opening existing funding programs for example, in Australia there was a solar-rebate program that was shut due to over-subscription. Adding money into this and re-opening would be a quick win as the bureaucracy already exists and nothing new has to be done.

Medium term require more time to get off the ground. The idea is these projects take over creating demand as the demand from the short term projects peters out. Examples of projects are:
  • National conduit system for communications (fibre). The idea is that the conduits are all built to the same design and can be undertaken by a multitude of companies across the country at the same time.
  • Installing Electrical re-charge stations would overcome the chicken and egg problem of getting plugin cars main stream. They would also reduce bills spent on petrol (gas), while stimulating demand to replace existing cars with plugin’s.
  • Replacing old bogies and busses and expanding the fleet will generate demand for manufacturing while improving the energy consumption of the economy. As per unit energy of transport falls productivity rises and frees up resources to be spent elsewhere. London Transport could certainly do with more upgrading the overground trains and increasing the size of the fleet. To say nothing of the underground.
Long term projects are generally large scale infrastructure projects that take time to get off the ground. These take over as the demand from medium term projects peter out. The type of projects I think should be funded are:
  • Fund mass transit systems in cities.
  • Fund fast rail projects linking up major cities. In Europe this would involve funding cross boarder connections and city bypasses.
  • Provide loans for large scale renewable energy projects. The loans provide the initial liquidity that is lacking at the moment and address the need to create green jobs.
  • Fund the extension of the power grid from sources to demand. This overcomes the chicken and egg problem that make a lot of large scale renewable energy projects dicey.

Development projects are only one part of the stimulus package. Additionally, help to start new and existing businesses is needed (many of the old businesses need to die as we progress from centralised to edge economy). For small business the hardest part is getting the capital/resources together to get the business to a point of being cashflow positive. Venture funding is not the answer. Most small businesses are not venture businesses but rather businesses that will turn a tidy profit but never exit.

For many (if not most) small businesses labour is the largest cost in the early years. To help new businesses start, governments need to provide income-contingent loans that pay salaries for up to 5 employees for the first year with an option to extend for a 2nd year. The income-contingent loans would be on the employee and not the business (reduces gaming of the system and also means the employees are invested in getting the business to succeed). Large numbers of new small business will go a long way to address demand destruction.
The government also needs to reduce the costs they impose on business through the amount they charge for services and cost of complying with regulation and legislation. This will free resources leading to increased investment and lower prices which benefit the economy overall.

Why energy, communications, transport and maintenance? Energy has two effects it addresses the simmering problem of peak oil and energy security (that hasn't gone away only been pushed to the background and will come roaring back soon). Additionally, by increasing energy efficiency cash is freed up (households, business and government) that can be used elsewhere whether repairing balance sheets faster or for consumption. Communications and transport projects also go to increasing energy security but primary reason is that improved communications and transport increase the productivity of the economy. Maintenance improves the performance of assets while also extending their life.

Moral hazard will be raised along with the supposed unfairness to people who where sensible. This is a concern but one that shouldn't, mustn't, hold up initiatives to break the spiral. The market can only work if there is a market and we are all part of a system. Just like destruction of one part of an ecosystem flows on to destroy other parts, so too will the spiral flow on to effect even the sensible. Within the three pronged approach you can put in place methods to address moral hazard and poor behaviour. For example, with the mortgage principal reduction the government can take a majority of any future realised capital gains. People who have the mortgage reset can also face additional credit restrictions in the future.

All of this is further complicated by the need for Western countries (particular the Anglo-Celtic countries) to coordinate the implementation of such a sweeping initiative. If the countries go it alone they will only make the whole job harder.

These are unusual times and call for unusual measures. The aim here is to reduce the crushing debt and cushion the economy from the plunge in demand by making it easier for new businesses to start and creating demand to replace some of what was lost. Make no mistake; the world will not return to levels of demand seen previously and the point of stimulus packages is to make the shift in the economy orderly rather than chaotic. Now is not the time for ideological battles or programs. The world needs pragmatism and the leadership to break the spiral and begin the path to recovery.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Breaking the Financial Spiral

Banknotes from all around the World donated by...Image via Wikipedia

Many have talked about how to solve the current crisis. I have my own view. I’ve written this as two comments so far; on Tom Evslin’s blog and Fred Wilson’s blog. At Fred’s suggestion and prompted by Neil Ferguson’s recent article in the Australian about similar proposal I’m turning this into a blog post.

The continual drip feed of rescues and bailouts is like keeping someone who has been bitten by a snake on life-support without removing the poison from the body and wondering why you have to keep treating heart attacks and seizures. Until the poison is removed from the body nothing is going to change. The economy is poisoned and the rescues and bailouts are doing nothing to remove the poison.

The poison is fear. Fear of investors who don’t know where the risk is and how risk exists. Fear of households who don’t know whether they will be able to keep food on the table or a roof over their heads. Fear breads fear. It feeds off it and becomes self perpetuating. To begin recovery, initiatives need to short circuit the fear.

The poison entered the system via inflated asset prices and loans. The principal on loans is simply too large. Now the loans are sucking up increasing amounts of income to pay off reducing consumption and increasing default rates, both feeding into the broader economy to reduce demand and in an on-going spiral leading to a recession, job losses and further defaults. As job losses mount consumers reduce their expenditure as they fear losing their own jobs and not being able to put food onto the table and a roof over their heads.

Investors injected fear as they suddenly found themselves in the unknown. Their safe investment s weren’t and now they had no idea where the risk is or how much, leaving them to stop investing and lending causing liquidity to dry up. The liquidity loss caused further increase in risk and default feeding further problems. It is all a spiral and until the spiral is broken it keeps going.

So far initiatives have halted the convulsions and resuscitated from heart attacks, but it is now time to draw the poison from the system.

Drawing the poison starts with loans. Until loans reflect the actual value of the assets, foreclosure rate will be high, subsidised payments and modifications notwithstanding. It simply doesn't make sense to continue to pay a mortgage, even at subsidised rates, when the value of the underlying asset is 20% or more less than the mortgage. In the end the mortgage principal needs to be reset to be within shouting distance of the underlying value of the asset.

Governments need to look at wholesale reduction in principal, something along the lines of financial institutions writing down the principal by 15 to 30%, the government purchasing 30% of the principal from the institutions. Depending on the location the Government can either write-off their purchase principal, suspend interest on their part of the principal or do nothing. The mortgage principal in effect is reduced by between 30 to 60%. The price of housing gets a massive reset to something resembling reason and underlying value. The principal reset has the effect of creating massive re-balancing of household balancesheets and freeing up income for discretionary spending.

Where it that simple of course. Unfortunately, underwater equity is only a small (although extremely toxic) part of the problem. The abject fear of not being able to keep food on the table and roof over their head is causing consumers to save. That fear undermines all stimulator policies. While new jobs may be created they are not going to be created fast enough to replace the jobs lost. Job loss happens far faster than job creation. The fear is creating a spiral to disaster that needs to be short-circuited. A short circuit would be to guarantee 75% to 90% of previous salary for a period of 12 to 24 months (the time length depends on time lag between job loss and job creation). This would remove the fear of not being able to buy food or keep a roof over their heads.

Existing unemployment benefits don't work in this situation as people can't downsize their life nor do you want people to down size their life quickly as that only exacerbates the asset and consumption problem. Broadly, the economy needs a short circuit and breathing room to allow stimulus and automatic re-adjustment to gain traction. The current disaster spiral overwhelms normal automatic adjustment in the economy.

Reducing principal and supporting salaries will draw the poison for the system and provide breathing space to begin recovery. But just like a patient, the economy needs physical therapy to return to full health. This is where the stimulus comes in.

Part 2: Stimulus and more
Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Digital Engagement - Making it Work

Digital Engagement, Gov 2.0 whatever moniker you want to use is on the up and up now. President Obama’s successful use of social networking and other social media tools during the campaign followed by the change.gov and new recovery.gov sites has brought the issue front and centre for many governments. In Australia both the PM and the Opposition Leader are on twitter and the Opposition Leader recently launched a blog for conversing with Australians. The UK government is hiring a Director of Digital Engagement and has a various initiatives like the Number 10 e-petition system.

For all the enthusiasm, Andy Oram wrote a very good post yesterday about the questions about government participation. For Governments and citizens looking at digital engagement, these questions have to be answered. Without answering these questions, initiatives will fail.

Is digital engagement worth it? It is as implemented well it has the following benefits:

  • Reduction in cost of compliance for business which leads to lower prices reducing cost of living,
  • Supports the flourishing of new businesses,
  • Lower cost to running the government, and
  • Improve perception of the value of government services.
While these benefits may not seem like much they produce a positive feedback loop that increases the overall value to society.

So the question isn’t so much whether we should do it but rather how do we do use digital engagement tools effectively?

Just get out of my Way

Digital Engagement isn’t simply about holding a conversation. The context matters. For example, if I am looking for the address of a service centre I don’t want to enter into a conversation. However, if there is a new bill on the table in parliament then I will want to join the conversation.

The minute digital engagement gets in the users way or adds no value to what they are doing at the time is when you get push back.

The context is king for digital engagement.

Policy and bills before parliament are a perfect example of where digital engagement can work extremely well. In this case the bills would be available online. It is to borrow a phrase, a social object. To bring engagement to policy and bills would be in the form of comment system like Disqus or Intense Debate. In essence each policy or bill becomes its own blog post.

Build a little, test a little

Rome wasn’t built in a day, but often initiatives such as digital engagement try to build Rome in a day. Instead, digital engagement should use Werner Von Braun’s engineering approach: build a little, test a little. The idea here is to build prototypes that are quickly deployed, which are then iterated based on user feedback. Trying to build an all encompassing solution simply chews up time especially when the users will start using the system in ways no designer could have foreseen. The evolution of Twitter is a great case study for how users take a system and begin using it in ways the designers and builders never expected.



Winning the Sceptics

Winning over the sceptics is likely to be the hardest part of any digital engagement initiative. Sceptics will question the value of digital engagement. They will also worry about how it changes their workload and job. Even for some whether it will mean losing their job. Others will ask whether the government will keep the conversation two-way. Addressing these real and legitimate concerns has to be the primary responsibility for those in charge of any digital engagement initiative.

The build a little, test a little approach neatly provides a way of demonstrating the value of digital engagement without extensive investment in time and money. Perhaps more importantly, it provides those involved with concrete and tangible feel for how their work will change.

The on-going involvement from both sides of the conversation will be the hardest to tackle. The key here is to be realistic. Fred Wilson continually points out how the community around his blog is built from his active involvement. For digital engagement to work, the public service and Government will have to participate in providing answers to comments and questions. Will Ministers and senior public servants want to do this? Some will and some won’t. The answer is to have “Untouchables”, “Community Managers” or “Community Advocates” who can effectively engage in the conversation.

Work/Life Balance

Drawing a line between work conversation and personal conversation is fraught but important for any digital engagement to succeed. Some organisations take the ridiculous view of everything being professional. It doesn’t work that way and is an imposition on people because organisations don’t want to address the issue at stake but instead repress it.

Mistakes will be made, gaffes will happen and the “wrong” thing said. Creating a policy that doesn’t address that is madness and will drive people (particularly Government and public servents) away from participation. Instead the policy needs to recognise when someone is a representative of the public service and government and when they are private citizens.

Showcasing Engagement

Without showcasing the prototypes across the Government and Public service web presence, all of the above will be wasted. Case in point, the OPSI “Unlock Service (beta)” is buried in the jungle of government portal pages. I only found it by accident. Given the importance of open government and digital engagement, this service needs to be showcased on the Direct.gov portal at the very least. Without making the prototypes, tools and developments that come out from a digital engagement initiative its very likely they will fail. In this President Obama’s Change.gov, Whitehouse.gov and recovery.gov are good examples of surfacing the tools.


Digital Engagement initiatives will change Government. How much change and how effectively they realise the benefits of Digital Engagement, depends on execution.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Monday, December 08, 2008

Reinventing the Wheel of Finance

National Bank of the Republic, Salt Lake City 1908Image via WikipediaOne of the ideas batted around every so often during the financial crisis is whether it would simply be easier and cheaper to create new banks and leave the old ones to die. On and off I’ve been thinking what this would mean. Which lead to the question of “are the current financial institutions the best way to manage capital?”

Banks have three primary roles: 1) store money 2) transfer money and 3) lending dormant money. Storing money is to the consumer the main view of banks. They store your money for you until you need it to pay bills and purchase stuff. Transfer money is what allows you to get your money from storage to where you needed it e.g. an ATM or to pay a bill online. Banks aggregate deposits and then lend this out of businesses and individuals to buy assets. It is this process that keeps money circulating and supports wealth creation.

There is no reason why these various roles need to be contained in one institution. We could in the future have one type of institution that stores money, another focused on transferring money and another on lending. What would happen if we separated these roles? For a majority of day-to-day banking tasks not much would outwardly change. The institution that stores your money would outwardly look like an existing bank with branches, debit cards and bank accounts. The transfer role is already there to an extent through various interbank agreements. Broadly, you won’t notice much.

Separate roles with be very noticeable in lending. Banks aggregate deposits and lend this out to individuals and businesses to buy assets (property, machinery etc.) Banks keep a percentage of deposits for people to use to pay bills and buy stuff. This works with the assumption that all the depositors are not going to need their money all at the same time. This process gives banks access to very cheap money which they can then lend out.

By separating the roles banks wouldn’t do the aggregation and lending. Instead those that lend would need to develop various ways to aggregate deposits from companies that store money in order to fund lending.
It is fair to ask whether this system would be more effective for society. I don’t know but it is worth exploring the idea. The advantages that I can see are:

  • Reduce conflict of interest between storing money and lending
  • Competition among deposit aggregators will produce a sustained increase the interest paid to depositors
  • It opens up the financial utility system for horizontal innovation and competition leading to better delivery of financial services
The existing banks and financial institutions will cry bloody murder as it attacks the status quo and potentially their profitability. However, they really haven’t demonstrated keen management of one of society’s key utilities. A potential more important issue is that individuals will be personally confronted with the idea that not all of their money is in their account. The existing illusion of your bank account actually having all your money ready to go will be stripped away as individuals have to decide how much of their account to lend to the aggregators. The removal of the illusion is very likely to create problems as people adjust to reality.

Separating the roles isn’t something that needs to be forced on existing players. Instead the various regulatory bodies should reform regulations to allow companies to step up and fulfil each role. Unleashing innovation in the delivery of financial utility (rather than in financial instruments) to society will do much to resolve the financial crisis.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Tuesday, November 18, 2008

How Can Australia Weather the Financial Storm?

Solar water heater on a rooftop in Jerusalem, ...Image via WikipediaAustralia, like the rest of the world, is coming under some battering from the financial crisis. It is worth looking at whether we can take advantage of the situation to make drastic improvements to the overall economy. Let’s begin by looking at where things stand.

Simple version is that the world is heading for recession and demand for Australian goods and services will go down. Various commentators and the Government have talked up China’s growth as keeping Australia from slipping into recession. I don’t think this is going to work. Wall Street Journal has reported a 4% drop in electricity consumption in China in October. Production of goods and services will fall due to the weakening demand in US and Europe, China’s key export markets which will mean China has less need for mineral commodities which has been the engine of Australia for the last few years.

The other idea floating around is that China and India’s middle class will continue to consume. Two problems with that, 1) Chinese and India’s middle class while big is not on the same scale in terms of consumption to replace the demand of the West and 2) much of the middle class in India and China are dependent on jobs that supply goods and services to Western consumers so as demand in the West falls expect to see the number of Chinese and Indian middle class fall. A lot of people don’t understand how the world’s growth has been due to the debt-fuelled consumption of the West. There is nothing to replace that demand.

As to weakening demand in the West a few simple yard sticks indicate that the de-leveraging still has away to go. House prices are still 3 times the average household income and household debt is still much greater than disposable income. In fact we still have yet to feel the effect of unsecured lending and credit card debt.
Unfortunately for Australia, the Government’s hasty and badly contrive deposit guarantee introduce instability into an otherwise stable financial system.

I expect that Australia will fall into recession and while the recession may not last very long the economy will remain flat until the system has de-leveraged itself back to more realistic levels. Golden years are over for now.

But...but this crisis is the single greatest opportunity Australia has to make a rapid shift, a quantum leap if you will, to a low carbon sustainable economy. Taking advantage of the crisis requires short, medium and long term initiatives by the Government, which meld together to shift people into green jobs, reduce per-capita energy consumption and prepare the ground for a low carbon economy by investing in key infrastructure.
Short term, Australia’s already had the fiscal stimulus (by short term I mean right now). That will hopefully keep things from falling off the cliff. Problem with giving money is a lot will go into paying down debt and less into consumption. An additional short term measure is to expand the solar hot water and solar power programs for household. This program already has the management systems in place and has been “closed” due to wild adoption. Simply by adding several hundred million dollars to the program, the number of installations can be increased creating jobs and reducing carbon creation.

Medium term (six months to a year) there are the tax cuts in July 2009. That won’t be enough and although the Government has talked about a 2nd stimulus package, that same money would be better spent focusing on the following initiatives:

  • Paying for low income and pension households to double glaze and insulate the homes, install solar hot water and high-efficiency air-conditioning;
  • Provide up-front income contingent loans to other households to do the same;
  • Fund the installation of solar panels and solar hot water on all government buildings and schools across Australia;
  • Soft loans to small business and commercial real-estate owners to install insulation, double glaze windows, install solar hot water and solar panels and purchase new high-efficiency machinery;
  • Revamp the car bail-out to allow people to trade to the government low millage cars for hybrid and electric cars;
  • Begin construction of a national conduit system across towns and cities starting in regional towns. The single biggest cost of laying fibre broadband is having to dig up the road. By creating a conduit system that anyone can get right of access to will allow new competitors to provide super fast (100+ Mbps symmetrical) to households. Additionally, conduits are standard so the contracts can be tendered to a wide range of construction companies creating short term jobs that are localised.
These initiatives will create green jobs, reduce the per-capita energy carbon energy consumption of Australia while also freeing up household income as utility bills are reduced. Again this income will initially go to paying down loans but then in about one year the income will move into demand replacing the spending of the Government initiatives.

Long term initiatives are everyone’s favourite infrastructure projects. The projects I see as having the best long term pay off are:
  • Fund a High Speed Rail on the East Coast initially connecting Sydney, Canberra and Melbourne with an option to Brisbane using TGV standard;
  • Fund the development of light rail in the major capital cities and regional centres;
  • Fund the development of DC High Voltage transmission lines that connect the centre of regional Australia to the major cities and regional towns.
All three of these initiatives would create a range of jobs over several years. They would also reduce the carbon footprint of the economy. The DC high voltage lines are important as they make large-scale solar more viable by providing an effective, low loss method of getting solar generated power to the cities. HSR can be started quickly by utilising the existing TGV standard and designing to support 500 km/h speeds.

The financial crisis offers the single greatest opportunity to cross the tipping point to a low carbon sustainable economy. A bit of fore thought and planning the Government (or Opposition) can make a huge difference to the country.
Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Thursday, July 31, 2008

Pulling out of recession

Most of the developed economies are facing a slow down if not a recession. Mark Cuban has described his method for pulling an economy out of recession. I broadly agree with his idea but I think that with an addition it address the biggest issues facing startups.

Startups (and small business as well) face two major hurdles or barriers to entry. The first is regulatory and the second is capital. Mark Cuban's plan address the regulatory barrier to entry and some of the capital issues (not paying taxes improves a companies cashflow). But it only goes so far. Not paying taxes is moot point if you don't have any revenue to support yourself.

To address the capital barrier, governments should implement a HELP-style business loan scheme. In this case the government would provide an initial loan that covers a single person's wage for a year. The loan could be renewed for a 1 year extension. The idea is that the load allows a small company to meet salary for initial employees during the launch phase when little to no revenue is available and other sources of funding are not useful.

The loan is then paid back through the tax system. The scheme would have several limits such as being limited to the average yearly wage and a company would only be allowed to ever have 5 employees use the scheme. Individuals would also need to be limited in the number of these loans that could be taken out within a time period (say once in a 5 year period).

The scheme is designed to allow people to take the plunge and spend that all important first year to get of the ground. It is very similar in intent to Ycombinator fund.

With Mark Cuban's plan addressing the regulatory burden faced by startups and small business the loan scheme addressing the initial capital requirements, people will find it easier to start a business and get it through that all important first year.

Economy, Mark Cuban, Finance, Policy

Sunday, April 20, 2008

The Best Regulation is Information

With the recent upheavals in the world financial markets there has already been calls to regulate. Arguably these calls are not wrong. The question, rather than should we regulate, is how and what do we regulate?

The financial crisis is one of market failure due to the lack of accurate and timely information about risk. The regulation needs to focus on correcting the issue of the markets providing accurate and timely information about risk.

The regulation needs to ensure that everyone involved in the market has knowledge of the real risk that various instruments and securities have. This will require the regulation of the ratings agencies as they failed to properly provide information on the risk involved in various securities. Or the rating of securities is handled by an independent body charged only with ensuring the risk of a security is accurately measured and information provided to the market.

The second bit of information is where the risk is. Here the accounting rules need to be change to ensure that risk cannot be shifted off-balance sheet so the risk "disappears". Essentially, if there is control and/or liability those risks need to show up on the balance sheet.

Sunday, March 23, 2008

Transparency and Morality in Business

Ross Gittins has an interesting article about the importance or requirement for moral values for a market to function properly. What struck me as interesting was the idea that markets function better when participants are able to judge the actions of other participants against social standards. This jives with what Umair Haque has written about numerous times around the DNA of businesses and the edge economy.

In previous posts, I've talked about the use of transparency of businesses to improve the DNA or the behaviour of businesses. The concept of being able to judge participants against social standards for honesty, trustworthiness etc. provide a strong foundation for judging what information participants need to provide about themselves.

By focusing on the information that allows judgments to be made about a company's behaviour meeting moral standards, we can avoid being inundated with information that is irrelevant and frankly unhelpful in creating better businesses and markets. Businesses are only as amoral as we allow them to be and there is no reason why a business has to amoral.

Tags: Transparency, Finance, Ross Gittins, Policy

Tuesday, February 26, 2008

Use a Time Slot Method for Train Travel

News comes today about First Great Western agreeing to a remedial plan to, well, operate a dependable train service. Rail franchises create a government granted monopoly on a rail line in exchange for meeting certain conditions. It is how the UK government decide to privatise rail travel.

I think rail franchises are the wrong way to organise the delivery of train services. Instead rail lines should be divided into time slots that a company bid for. Obviously lucrative spots would be bid higher and less lucrative spots would be less expensive. The idea is to create system like landing slots at airports. This would allow various train companies to compete on the same line which would drive prices lower and also increase the number of services.

Part of rail franchises sometimes includes revamping railway stations. This could still be done using with time slots by directing the money from the auction of the slots into track and station improvements and/or also charge a "standing fee" for each train.

Monopolies are a bad way to deliver a service. Competition will do more to improve train service particularly if the slots are auction for periods of between 1 to 5 years and any single company cannot by two (three?) consecutive slots so that a user has a choice of waiting for the next train.

The main hurdle to slot base method is the management of arrivals. Systems will need to be in place for dealing with late trains - perhaps by moving them off into holding points until a slot is free.

Tags: Rail Franchise, Rail, UK, Transport

Saturday, February 23, 2008

Using transparency to regulate business

For a while I've regarded the use of transparency as a better way to regulate than brute force of law. In an interesting piece on lateral thinking in economics Ross Gittins, discusses the work of Dr Guren of Lateral Economics.

Many of the ideas proposed by Dr. Guren are not really new or innovative, if you've been following economics and the open movement. Taxing "bads" as opposed to "goods" are known as Pigovian Taxes. What I did find interesting was Dr. Guren's idea around improving health & safety in the workplace by this method:

Most workers care about workplace safety, but typically lack information about it when applying for a job. Yet the workers' compensation premiums paid by firms provide a good proxy for their past occupational health and safety performance.

We should publish them, Dr Gruen says, and require that existing and prospective employees are provided with information on how they compare with economy-wide and industry-wide average performance.

I already think that salaries should be published by each company. Publishing the salaries and benefits across the organisation, will promote competition between companies for labour. One of the key problems with the labour market has moved beyond flexibility, to information asymmetry. A real market can't exist with this asymmetry whether a market is flexible or not.

But the idea of publishing H&S premiums has got me wondering what other internal information should be published to make companies more transparent and so reduce the amount of regulation and enforcement action needed in the economy?

Off the top of my head I can think of:

  • Number of harassment claims filed
  • Amount of energy KWh used by the company
The more simple and available the information the easier it is to counter arguments about cost and burden. The use of open information would have a profound effect on the economy and the regulation of business.

Tags: Open Source, Policy


Friday, February 22, 2008

Meddling polies should focus on what matters

I understand the need for regulation and laws, but it annoys me when polies meddle in areas for the sake of being seen to do some thing. The UK government is threatening legislation to penalise ISPs for not blocking privacy. The really idiotic thing is the UK government has already said their idea falls afoul of UK and EU data privacy laws. So what's going to happen? The government will pass the law, the ISPs will challenge in the UK and EU and the law will be rule illegal. So back to drawing board with the only accomplished is a lot of money spent on lawyers and the government been seen to do something.

Beyond the technical hurdles, there is also the political fallout from the law being overturned plus the damage this will do to a government tettering on the brink. I wonder if this new push has arisen when someone pointed out wholesale kicking off of downloaders is likely to lose Labour votes.

To me, this is massive over-reaction to a relative minor problem. Stopping downloading of content is not going to be a saviour of society nor cure its ills. There are far more pressing problems in the economy that WILL do massive amount of damage to peoples lives - credit crisis, stagflation, deep recession - that the government should be worrying about. Protecting an outdated business model is NOT the governments job.

This legislation has the air of desperation. Of a government looking down a yawing canyon of irrelevance and trying deperately to be seen to be doing something, anything.

Fiddling while Rome(London) burns.

Tags: UK Government, UK, ISPs, Policy

Wednesday, February 20, 2008

Fighting Inflation in Australia using Super

Australia is one of the few nations in the world where the interest rates are rising and rising hard. Commodities boom, over indulgent consumption and 35 year lows in employment have pushed the economy to the limits of capacity.

The debate in Australia is about how to fight the inflation and the recurrent need for the RBA to raise interest rates to combat inflation now outside its 2-3% band. The Rudd Government has brought back fiscal policy to try and help fight inflation by aiming for a surplus of 1.5 to 2% and avoid the RBA rasing interest rates further (unlikely). Although given that for the past 5 years or so the budget surplus has always come in higher that the forecasted 1% its hard to see how a measly 1.5 to 2% is going to make much of difference. It probably needs to be 2.5 to 3%.

The otherside of the debate is how raising interest rates is a blunt policy instrument for fighting inflation, only effects third of households etc. What is missing from the debate is discussion on what other levers that could be provided to the RBA to manage the economy. In many economies there probably aren't many other levers that central banks could use. But Australia has compulsory super for a majority of employed people. The issue is to remove spending from the economy or put another way to increase savings and reducing consumption. Giving the RBA the ability to manage the percentage of income that is paid into super would give the RBA another lever to pull.

The advantages I see in using super contributions this way are;

  • It increases the savings rate across a very large majority of households
  • It does not directly effect the price of business investment the way interest rates do
  • It is spread more evenly across the economy rather than concetrated in the 1/3 of households with morgages
  • Individuals don't lose the money, it is simply redistribute to return in the future
The biggest problem I see is the mechanics of actually performing the changes. However, this is a solvable problem as it could rolled into financial packages that most if not all businesses use.

Another possible lever is to allow the RBA to change tax percentages about a median point. But I see that being an even tougher operation and also more politically hazardous. It could be a rather useful tool to have in the back pocket though.

Tags: Superannuation, Inflation, Australia

Tuesday, February 19, 2008

Incentives cause the [financial] rot

Umair has a new post about the financial meltdown and in particular how the very people at the centre of the meltdown are walking away with massive payments. I think there is a lot about how the very incentive system used by financial institutions are at the very core of the problem.

The incentive systems are probably the single biggest cause of the problems. These systems are designed to maximise profit - which is not the same as wealth creation. The assumption that serves as the foundation of incentive systems is that the "agents" interests need to be aligned with the "owners". An assumption that I now believe is totally invalid.

The incentive systems need to promote wealth creation and not alignment of the interests. Otherwise why will an executive take a risk that has a long term payoff but will hit short-term profitability?

So how do you fix something so broken. The first is to ditch the assumption of aligning the "agents" interest with the "owners" interest. The second is to ditch the idea that a single person at the level of CEO has much effect on the overall profitability of a company. Suddenly it gets hard to justify paying ANYONE 100m salary. Indeed, CEOs make a mockery of their own job - if the share price goes down its due to the market, but if it goes up its due to the skill of the CEO. Spot the paradox?

Can the market sort this out itself? Probably not. Too much self-interest. This leads to the requirement of regulation. The key is to regulate well but lightly. Some regulation will require the out-right banning of current practices, while others are about increasing transparancy and market efficiency.

Golden parachutes need to be banned. Why a CEO should receive money to leave a job is beyond me. The sub-prime crisis has shown this for the rort it is. Which does lead to the second requirement of having all senior management and possibly contracts above a certain value requiring the agreement of a quorum of shareholders. The current negogiation world is far to cosy.

In terms of increasing transparancy, the renumeration and contracts of senior management should be published. This works fine but it helps to have this put in perspective of the how well the company is paying its employees. So companies should be required to publish the various renumeration bands, the requirements for bonuses at these bands and the number of employees per band.

But perhaps the biggest change is to remove incentive schemes that promote short-term profit over long-term wealth creation. Most of the current methods can and are easily gamed. Whether it is EPS, dividends, profit, revenue or share price increase. Most of these items are reflective of things beyond the senior managements control. So the first step is to only use measures that are effected by senior management actions. More important is only use actions that promote wealth creation (as opposed to profit).

So what measures could be used?

  • Employee productivity per unit cost
  • Throughput per unit cost
  • Employee statisfaction
  • Revenue growth per unit of productivty
  • Productivity growth per employee
And there are more. Most of these measures are harder to game but they are all measuring changes that change the long term wealth creation of the company. Funnily enough, most of these would reduce the awards of financial executives.

Incentive systems and the spiralling cost of financial executives is something that needs to be addressed. Otherwise you run the risk of societal unrest. Perhaps more importantly these spiralling costs are also a distortion of the market causing the mis-allocation of resources and dragging down GDP growth.

Wednesday, January 23, 2008

EU energy plan aims to stop carbon exporting

The EU has announced its climate change policy. What struck me most is the move to stop the exporting of carbon production to other countries. As I have previously posted this is crucial requirement for carbon trading to actual work in reducing carbon emissions.

Implementing carbon trading without something to address the issue of out-sourcing carbon, the price of goods and services in Europe would have gone up without the beneficial reduction in carbon. As many have pointed out, there is no way of making sure carbon stays on the other side of the planet.

This also changes the dynamics of the up-coming discussions on the next climate change treaty. For one, it does reduce the negotiating strength of the BRIC nations against mandatory caps. It also precedes an alliance of OECD nations which go it alone to implement mandatory emission caps and via the mechanism proposed by the EU in effect force mandatory caps on emissions on the rest of the world as the OECD still make up the bulk of the worlds affluent consumers.

I wonder if this announcement signals the tipping point to worldwide mandatory emissions caps whether BRIC nations want it or not.

Tags: Climate Change